By using this site, you agree to the Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.
Accept
RealEstate NicheRealEstate Niche
  • Realtor
    Realtor
    In this day and age everyone has access to the same information & listings. Distribution is no longer a major value component that a real…
    Show More
    Top News
    4 Tips for Buying Your First Home, Millennials and Young Couples Must Read!
    1 year ago
    Realtor.com releases 2023 housing market predictions
    9 months ago
    Josh Flagg Blows Up While Discussing Divorce from Bobby Boyd on ‘Million Dollar Listing LA’: ‘I’m Not Pleased’
    Josh Flagg Blows Up While Discussing Divorce from Bobby Boyd on ‘Million Dollar Listing LA’: ‘I’m Not Pleased’
    9 months ago
    Latest News
    A Luxury Bardominium and Parade of Homes Winner in Indiana Is the Week’s Most Popular Home
    2 months ago
    Christine Girouard, Jonathan Dauphinais-Fortin suspended after fraud investigation
    2 months ago
    What Can We Expect for the Second Half of This Year?
    2 months ago
    ChatGPT Content Marketing Prompts: Easy Way to Make Your Content Stand Out
    2 months ago
  • Land
    Land
      We will continue to keep you updated on all the latest land news as it happens!
    Show More
    Top News
    Home Staging and Decorating projects
    1 year ago
    Ontario passes housing bill amid criticism from cities, conservation authorities
    1 year ago
    Eagle viewing excursions offered at Land Between the Lakes
    Eagle viewing excursions offered at Land Between the Lakes
    9 months ago
    Latest News
    Intense “No Man’s Land” at Steppenwolf stars Jeff Perry
    2 months ago
    Ukraine’s allies are shifting focus from donating weapons to fixing them as Western-supplied armor proves resilient to Russian fire, reports say
    2 months ago
    Universal Orlando Resort to Add DreamWorks Animation Land in 2024
    2 months ago
    Passenger, 68, crash lands plane on Martha’s Vineyard after the pilot’s medical emergency
    2 months ago
  • Sell Home
    Sell Home
    Selling a home can be a daunting task, but with the right preparation it can be a relatively easy process. The first step is to…
    Show More
    Top News
    The Insider: Clinton Hill 13-Footer Gains Light, Function, Storage in Parlor-Floor Renovation
    1 year ago
    House sells for $2.5 million in Miami Beach, Florida
    10 months ago
    Windsor Terrace Co-op With Two Bedrooms, Period Moldings, Parquet Asks $875K
    Windsor Terrace Co-op With Two Bedrooms, Period Moldings, Parquet Asks $875K
    8 months ago
    Latest News
    Work Starts to Transform Crown Heights Parking Lot Into Affordable Housing
    2 months ago
    Another Hot Summer Brings Concerns About Access to Brooklyn Cooling Centers
    2 months ago
    Seven-Bedroom Ditmas Park West Standalone Asks $6,950 a Month
    2 months ago
    Brooklyn News: Affordable Housing Lottery in East New York
    2 months ago
  • Rent Out Property
    Rent Out Property
    Choose the right property. Not all properties are created equal when it comes to renting them out. You’ll want to choose a property that is…
    Show More
    Top News
    KINSELLA: US Supreme Court tosses principle that holds law together
    1 year ago
    ‘A beautiful thing,’ the former Cambridge resident says of finally living out the Canadian dream
    ‘A beautiful thing,’ the former Cambridge resident says of finally living out the Canadian dream
    9 months ago
    Why rent is so expensive in 3 Canadian cities (that aren’t Toronto or Vancouver)
    Why rent is so expensive in 3 Canadian cities (that aren’t Toronto or Vancouver)
    7 months ago
    Latest News
    Rate Hikes Hit the Rental Market
    2 months ago
    ‘It really seems like no one cares about us:’ City was forced to evict tenants of rooming house
    2 months ago
    5 Questions To Ask Yourself When Purchasing Property For An AirBnB
    2 months ago
    More Canadians turn to short-term rentals to earn extra cash, maintain properties
    2 months ago
  • Real Estate News
    Real Estate NewsShow More
    The Best Areas of Southampton to Invest in Buy-to-Let
    2 months ago
    The Best Areas of Brighton and Hove to Invest in Buy-to-Let
    2 months ago
    Sale of two Vancouver towers a big test for office real estate market
    2 months ago
    The Best Areas of Bristol to Invest in Buy-to-Let
    2 months ago
    The Best Areas of Nottingham to Invest in Buy-to-Let
    2 months ago
Reading: Surrey homeowners fined for ongoing illegal rentals
Share
Aa
RealEstate NicheRealEstate Niche
Aa
Have an existing account? Sign In
Follow US
© 2022 Foxiz News Network. Ruby Design Company. All Rights Reserved.
Rent Out Property

Surrey homeowners fined for ongoing illegal rentals

michika
Last updated: 2022/09/18 at 5:31 AM
michika 1 year ago
Share
SHARE

Homeowners in Surrey who turned a single-family home into an “unauthorized and unpermitted” four-plex could be on the hook for as much as $19,000 after defying a court order telling them to stop renting out the suites, a judge has ruled.

Contents
CONTEMPT OF THE INJUNCTION THE PENALTY THE NEED FOR DETERRENCE

A BC Supreme Court decision posted online Tuesday outlines the history of the dispute between the City of Surrey and property owners Sukhdev Singh and Kashmir Singh Sahota.

According to the court documents, the home was purchased in 2021 and the owners proceeded with “extensive renovations.” By March of 2022, a two-suite addition had been built and a secondary suite had been added.

“The City of Surrey alleges the respondents did so without permits or required inspections and contrary to the ‘stop work’ orders, tickets, warnings from the City of Surrey, and the applicable bylaws,” the court heard.


CONTEMPT OF THE INJUNCTION

In April, the city applied for and was granted an injunction that ordered the owners to stop renting out the units. In September, they were found in contempt of that order.

“Despite the April order, the respondents continued to use the addition and the secondary suite as three separate rental units, which have been occupied by third parties in exchange for payment to the respondents,” wrote Justice John Gibb-Carsley, summarizing his decision to find them in contempt.

“The respondents have also been using the upper floor of the house as a fourth rental unit for tenants.”


THE PENALTY

At a November hearing, Gibb-Carsley provided his reasons for imposing an immediate financial penalty of $6,000 for the breach of the court order and a further $13,000 to be paid if the suites remained occupied on Jan. 1, 2023.

The City of Surrey argued that the owners made no attempt to “purge the contempt” by having the tenants vacate the property. The judge’s decision noted that the owners provided signed agreements from three of the tenants saying they would leave – but that they were dated only one day before the hearing.

For their part, the owners told the court they knew they were violating city bylaws and the court order by renovating and renting the suites.

“The respondents stated that they ‘never thought it would get this far.’ They said that so many other people in Surrey are doing the same thing—that is, building and renting suites without permission—that they did not think this would happen,” the decision said.

Singh and Sahota said they had “made sincere efforts” and spent a considerable amount of money trying to retroactively get the necessary building permits from the city.

Further, they said it was difficult to get the tenants to leave because “the respondents charge a low rent and … it is very difficult to find similar rental accommodations in the Lower Mainland.” However, the judge said he had seen no evidence that there had been “concrete efforts” made to remove the tenants.


THE NEED FOR DETERRENCE

Gibb-Carsley, when explaining why he ordered the fine that he did, stressed the need to deter people from “blatantly” disregarding court orders. He also agreed with the City of Surrey that there are potential safety consequences to flouting building codes and the permitting process – even if these particular suites did not present any immediate danger.

“The practice of offering unlawful suites for rent and inviting members of the public to occupy uninspected buildings without occupancy permits to my mind poses at least a theoretical risk to the health and safety of the community,” he wrote.

“To think otherwise would render the municipal building and occupancy bylaws meaningless.”

In considering an appropriate penalty for the owners if they continue to rent out the suites past the Dec. 31 deadline, the judge said it needed to be significant enough to “blunt any financial incentives the respondents may have in continuing to remain in contempt.”

Singh and Sahota have also been ordered to pay the municipality’s legal costs.

“Given the City of Surrey is a local government, funded by taxpayers’ dollars, and was required to incur the costs of these contempt proceedings solely because of the respondents’ actions, it is appropriate,” Gibb-Carsley wrote.

“I have some sympathy for the respondents and their stated belief that they could apply after the fact to remedy their various infractions. However, in my view, their actions have forced the City of Surrey to take steps and incur costs to enforce orders of this court.”

TAGGED: how to rent my house, how to rent out a house in california, how to rent property, renting out your property, renting out your property privately
michika September 18, 2022
Share this Article
Facebook Twitter Email Print
Previous Article Realtors association unveils its first new headquarters in decades
Next Article How Do Tax Deed Auctions Work? The Process Explained
Recent Post

Excessive Street Fashion Chain Launches Huge Closing Down Sale Is A Shop Close To You Going?

michika By michika 10 hours ago
Pets On The Market In The Uk
Property, Houses & Flats For Sale & To Rent
Ministers Criticised For Scrapping New Meals Waste Legal Guidelines For England Meals Waste
Sports A-z Bbc Sport
- Advertisement -
Ad imageAd image
Search

Stay Connected

Our Project

Land
Real Estate News
Sell Home
Rent Out Property
Realtor

Find Us on Socials

RealEstate NicheRealEstate Niche

© koab News Network. Ruby Theme Design Company. All Rights Reserved.

  • Advertise Here
  • Contact Us
  • Disclosure Policy
  • Sitemap

Removed from reading list

Undo
Welcome Back!

Sign in to your account

Register Lost your password?